CigarBid Tracker

Know what cigars actually sell for

CigarBid vs Retail

Cigars where the retailer actually beats CigarBid’s auction average. Happens on JoeCigar specials + CI loss-leader samplers. Per-stick, using real shelf prices.
30 cigars · 180-day CigarBid avg · only cigars with 3+ closes in the window
English Dutch
CigarBid wins Retail wins
# Cigar CigarBid avg/stick CI/stick CI saves Proof
🥇 Montecristo White Churchill (10) Montecristo · 49 closes $10.56 $0.79 93% cheaper $9.77/stick CI →
🥈 Montecristo White Toro - 5-Pack Montecristo · 53 closes $9.10 $0.79 91% cheaper $8.31/stick CI →
🥉 Montecristo White Label Toro (27) Montecristo · 8 closes $9.04 $0.79 91% cheaper $8.25/stick CI →
4 Montecristo White Churchill (Single) Montecristo · 47 closes $8.82 $0.79 91% cheaper $8.03/stick CI →
5 Montecristo White #2 Belicoso (Single) Montecristo · 13 closes $8.65 $0.79 91% cheaper $7.86/stick CI →
6 Punch Champion (Single) Punch · 38 closes $5.01 $0.60 88% cheaper $4.41/stick CI →
7 Hoyo Excalibur #1 · 31 closes $5.12 $0.67 87% cheaper $4.45/stick CI →
8 Hoyo Excalibur No. 660 (20) · 55 closes $4.13 $0.65 84% cheaper $3.48/stick CI →
9 Hoyo Excalibur No. 1 Maduro - Box of 20 · 138 closes $4.11 $0.65 84% cheaper $3.46/stick CI →
10 Punch Magnum - Box of 25 Punch · 9 closes $3.78 $0.60 84% cheaper $3.18/stick CI →
11 Excalibur #1 (20) · 193 closes $4.20 $0.67 84% cheaper $3.53/stick CI →
12 Punch Champion (25) Punch · 32 closes $3.72 $0.61 84% cheaper $3.11/stick CI →
13 ACID by Drew Estate 1400cc (Single) ACID Cigars · 24 closes $9.12 $1.52 83% cheaper $7.61/stick CI →
14 Punch After Dinner Natural (25) Punch · 25 closes $3.49 $0.60 83% cheaper $2.89/stick CI →
15 Punch Rothschild Double Maduro Punch · 6 closes $3.50 $0.61 83% cheaper $2.89/stick CI →
16 Punch After Dinner Maduro (25) Punch · 16 closes $3.25 $0.60 82% cheaper $2.65/stick CI →
17 ACID Extra Ordinary Larry (10) ACID Cigars · 48 closes $8.03 $1.52 81% cheaper $6.51/stick CI →
18 Punch Fresh Pack Robusto Punch · 54 closes $3.16 $0.61 81% cheaper $2.55/stick CI →
19 ACID Extra Ordinary Larry (Single) ACID Cigars · 86 closes $7.80 $1.52 81% cheaper $6.28/stick CI →
20 ACID Kuba Grande (Gordo) - 5-Pack ACID Cigars · 74 closes $7.66 $1.52 80% cheaper $6.14/stick CI →
21 ACID Kuba Grande - Box of 10 ACID Cigars · 15 closes $7.65 $1.52 80% cheaper $6.13/stick CI →
22 Punch After Dinner - 5-Pack Punch · 242 closes $2.87 $0.60 79% cheaper $2.27/stick CI →
23 Punch Rothschild - 5-Pack Punch · 305 closes $2.70 $0.60 78% cheaper $2.10/stick CI →
24 ACID by Drew Estate Kuba Candela ACID Cigars · 57 closes $6.77 $1.52 78% cheaper $5.25/stick CI →
25 ACID Extra Ordinary Larry - 5-Pack ACID Cigars · 66 closes $6.35 $1.52 76% cheaper $4.83/stick CI →
26 ACID by Drew Estate Plush ACID Cigars · 53 closes $6.33 $1.52 76% cheaper $4.81/stick CI →
27 ACID by Drew Estate Plush ACID Cigars · 41 closes $6.26 $1.52 76% cheaper $4.74/stick CI →
28 Tabak Especial by Drew Estate Toro Dulce - 5-Pack · 261 closes $7.56 $1.84 76% cheaper $5.72/stick CI →
29 Punch Rothschild Maduro - 5-Pack Punch · 92 closes $2.45 $0.61 75% cheaper $1.84/stick CI →
30 Drew Estate Tabak Especial Toro Dulce (Single) · 207 closes $7.14 $1.84 74% cheaper $5.30/stick CI →

How to read this

  • Per-stick. Retailers push box-of-20 so the sticker price looks small; CigarBid auctions the same cigar as 10-packs or 5-packs. Comparing totals would lie — per-stick is the honest number.
  • CigarBid average, not one-off lucky closes. The green number is a rolling 180-day average across every auction that closed. Cigars with fewer than 3 closes are excluded.
  • English and Dutch are separated. Dutch auctions run hotter on average, so mixing them would flatten the signal. Use the toggle to switch.
  • "Proof" opens the retailer's listing in a new tab so you can verify the price yourself. Retail prices move, we refresh on a delay.