CigarBid Tracker

Know what cigars actually sell for

CigarBid vs Retail

Cigars where CigarBid auctions close cheapest vs. the actual shelf price at CI. Comparison is per-stick, and the retail side uses the current sale price (not the fake MSRP).
30 cigars · 180-day CigarBid avg · only cigars with 3+ closes in the window
English Dutch
CigarBid wins Retail wins
# Cigar CigarBid avg/stick CI/stick You save Proof
🥇 Oliva 5-Star Sampler #3 Oliva · 39 closes $4.17 $7.40 44% off $3.23/stick CI →
🥈 Torano Family Reunion Mega-Sampler Torano · 49 closes $2.64 $4.50 41% off $1.86/stick CI →
🥉 AJ Fernandez BP Perfecto Mega-Sampler II · 183 closes $3.57 $6.00 41% off $2.43/stick CI →
4 Man O’ War Mega-Sampler II Man O' War · 29 closes $3.58 $5.75 38% off $2.17/stick CI →
5 Diesel Unholy Cocktail Mega-Sampler Diesel · 27 closes $3.23 $5.00 35% off $1.77/stick CI →
6 AJ Fernandez Top Ten Sampler · 36 closes $5.18 $8.00 35% off $2.82/stick CI →
7 AJ Fernandez Anthology Sampler · 107 closes $3.24 $5.00 35% off $1.76/stick CI →
8 HC Series Flight Sampler HC Series · 26 closes $2.66 $4.06 35% off $1.40/stick CI →
9 Legends by Drew Estate Mega-Sampler · 108 closes $4.11 $6.25 34% off $2.14/stick CI →
10 Monte & Romeo Mega-Sampler · 35 closes $4.29 $6.50 34% off $2.21/stick CI →
11 Comfortably Numb by Espinosa Sampler · 104 closes $4.33 $6.53 34% off $2.20/stick CI →
12 Caldwell Mega-Sampler · 168 closes $4.00 $6.00 33% off $2.00/stick CI →
13 The Chosen One V · 226 closes $3.24 $4.86 33% off $1.62/stick CI →
14 Drew Estate Ultimate Infused Mega-Sampler · 85 closes $4.55 $6.80 33% off $2.25/stick CI →
15 Gurkha Ultimate Smorgasbord Sampler Gurkha · 85 closes $3.38 $5.00 32% off $1.62/stick CI →
16 Oliva Master Blends 3 Mega-Sampler Oliva · 176 closes $4.30 $6.30 32% off $2.00/stick CI →
17 Montecristo Platinum Flight Sampler Montecristo · 38 closes $5.07 $7.33 31% off $2.26/stick CI →
18 Rocky Patel ITC Super Fuerte Mega-Sampler · 8 closes $3.04 $4.25 29% off $1.21/stick CI →
19 Nub Mega-Sampler · 74 closes $4.00 $5.50 27% off $1.50/stick CI →
20 #25: Tabak Especial and CAO Moontrance · 264 closes $4.05 $5.50 26% off $1.45/stick CI →
21 Drew Estate Motherlode Sampler · 53 closes $4.43 $5.71 22% off $1.28/stick CI →
22 Drew Estate's Brew Estate Mega-Sampler · 79 closes $4.71 $6.00 21% off $1.29/stick CI →
23 #26: CAO Brazilia and Rocky Patel Edge · 55 closes $3.87 $4.80 19% off $0.93/stick CI →
24 Diesel Anthology Sampler Diesel · 46 closes $4.92 $6.11 19% off $1.19/stick CI →
25 Camacho Mega-Sampler II Camacho · 178 closes $4.07 $5.00 19% off $0.93/stick CI →
26 Drew Estate ACID Collector's Tin ACID Cigars · 34 closes $5.16 $6.33 18% off $1.17/stick CI →
27 Plasencia 6-Cigar Robusto Collection · 88 closes $12.33 $15.00 18% off $2.67/stick CI →
28 Oliva Motherlode Sampler Oliva · 109 closes $3.80 $4.57 17% off $0.77/stick CI →
29 The NUB-erlode Sampler II · 349 closes $3.71 $4.40 16% off $0.69/stick CI →
30 Gurkha Classics Mega-Sampler Gurkha · 20 closes $3.49 $3.75 7% off $0.26/stick CI →

How to read this

  • Per-stick. Retailers push box-of-20 so the sticker price looks small; CigarBid auctions the same cigar as 10-packs or 5-packs. Comparing totals would lie — per-stick is the honest number.
  • CigarBid average, not one-off lucky closes. The green number is a rolling 180-day average across every auction that closed. Cigars with fewer than 3 closes are excluded.
  • English and Dutch are separated. Dutch auctions run hotter on average, so mixing them would flatten the signal. Use the toggle to switch.
  • "Proof" opens the retailer's listing in a new tab so you can verify the price yourself. Retail prices move, we refresh on a delay.